*****SPOILERS AHEAD*****
Hooray, we finally got another Sayid episode! I think it was right around this time in Season 3 when a Sayid episode, "Enter 77", pushed the accelerate button on the plot line and sent the whole rest of that slow-starting season into overdrive. I'm guessing that at the end of Season 5, we just might look at "He's Our You" in the same way. Sayid is such a great character, and all of the amazing things about him were explored tonight - his dual nature of being a trained and often willing killer at the same time that he has tremendous regrets, his kick-ass fighting skills, his skill with the ladies, and, for all his strategic nature, his too frequent tendency to just trust the wrong person.
Before I get to much more about the plot development, I have to thank the lost writers outright for giving us not one, but TWO, of my new all-time favorite LOST lines tonight:
"A 12-year-old Ben Linus brought me a chicken sandwich. How do you think I'm doing?" - Sayid to LaFleur/Sawyer
"Three years, no burning buses. Y'all are back for ONE day....!" - LaFleur/Sawyer to Jack and KateThose just made me giggle! Okay, back to the story.
Sayid Jarrah, this is your life...
We certainly saw some of the highlights, from way back in Tikrit when an adorable little Sayid first showed his killer tendencies (and showed us that like so many characters in LOST he has a domineering father), to the return of the fluffy-haired Oceanic 6 assassin and the repentant charity homebuilder in the Dominican Republic. And, perhaps most importantly, we learned more about the mysterious and slightly-scary Ilana and why Sayid was her prisoner on the Ajira flight. Retribution catches up with him... or does it?
A lot of holes were filled in, including the many key conversations between Sayid and Ben. Once again we see that Ben is a master manipulator (forcing him to become an assassin then just dropping him with no next plan, lying to him about John Locke's death and always threatening that his friends were in danger) and his words often helped shape Sayid's motivations and in some ways helped define who he had become. Let's not forget that key moment when Ben, who has been the scourge of Sayid's life, pushing and pulling him to his own needs for years, reminded him "You're a killer." It's reached the point where even Sayid believes that is what he truly is. (Although I want to believe he still knows he has a good heart in there... like all sexy but vulnerable bad boys...)
Back in DharmaLand, circa 1977...
In the midst of the glimpses of Sayid's past (which is, of course, in the future on this show), we had a very tense storyline that revolved around the question of "what do we do with the prisoner?" Sound familiar???? There's some great blog writing out there that theorizes that the seasons of LOST will end up paralleling each other. That 4 was a parallel to 3, and now that Season 5 is nicely lining up with Season 2 (and thus that the final season would echo the first). Our Survivors integrating themselves in Dharma, dealing with the Hostiles, learning all these Island secrets, feels very similar to Season 2 with the Hatch and the Tailies and the Others. And what mysterious prisoner first appeared in Season 2? Why, that would be none other than Henry Gale, aka our introduction to the inimitable Benjamin Linus. At first, that's what I thought they meant by "He's Our You," which still seems a good parallel.
But that title was actually a line from LaFleur/Sawyer (I really am starting to think of LaFleur as almost a different character, well played Josh Holloway). After numerous attempts to try to get his old friend to play along with the charade, LaFleur/Sawyer was outvoted on being patient and Sayid was subjected to the Dharmites' interrogator -- Oldham. This creepy old dude - played by William Sanderson, who looked so familiar to me it was driving me nuts until I realized I was used to seeing him with his brother Darryl and his *other* brother Darryl - living out in his teepee in the jungle fed Sayid some crazy truth serum. And boy oh boy, our trained Iraqi Republican Guard guy was not immune. He started talking like a crazy little child, telling them the whole story, much to LF/Sawyer's chagrin. I think he almost had Horace (aka Eugene Tooms of X-Files fame) and crazy Radzsinsky believing him, until he went a little too far by shouting "I am from the future!" :-)
The Dharmites don't buy this story (would you?) and instead calls for a very "civilized" house meeting and vote on Sayid's fate. Radzinsky is still all crazy about the Swan, which apparently hasn't been named yet, and is sure that Sayid is a spy. LF/Sawyer seems to be putting up a good fight on exercising caution and giving him another chance to talk until new mom Amy chimes in (damn you Michele Dessler!) about worrying about baby Ethan (creepy little bastard) as long as Sayid's around. So the group votes to kill Sayid, and LF/Sawyer is pressured into making it unanimous.
Trying yet again to save his friend, LF/Sawyer visits Sayid... offers him a chance at escape... but Sayid refuses and gives a very resigned speech about waking up back on the Island and finally knowing what his purpose was. Here, I thought, Sayid's finally seeking redemption and thinks dying is the only way to make up for his life of sin. I was afraid for a few moments there that the show might actually kill Sayid... that would've been shocking, but the moment *almost* felt right. Instead, we got another shock... which brings me to...
"If I Only Had a Purpose"
The real meat of this episode..... the relationship between Sayid and Ben. For the last 3+ years of his life, Sayid has been totally dominated by Ben Linus. He hates him, thinks he's evil, but has still worked for him and often follows his lead. What is this power Ben has over him? What made Ben this way?
Well.... we got to see a little start of that tonight. Cuz after last week's big reveal of that 12-year-old and his sandwich, tonight we saw how young Ben looked up to the prisoner Sayid, how he was humiliated by his father in front of him (more LOST daddy issues), how he begged to be brought over by Sayid to the Others. And at some point, Sayid realized his true purpose... at least the way he saw it upon returning to the Island back in 1977... in the moment, I thought he meant his purpose was to CREATE Ben Linus.
But, with that final, shocking scene.... after little Ben let Sayid go and finally had a leader, a mentor to take him into the jungle and help him escape his wretched Dharma life... after lying to Jin and then knocking him out... Sayid did the unthinkable. HE SHOT LITTLE BEN.
Hominawhat?!?!?!?!?
Put that in our closed time loop and smoke it! Where's Daniel Faraday when we need him??? If he shot little Ben, can he kill him? You can't kill 12-year-old Ben when we know damn well Ben lives into his 40's, right? Set aside dates here, this is about linear age... Ben grows older. We know that! So either that was a non-fatal close-range gunshot wound to the chest, which means adult Ben will know all along that Sayid shot him back in 1977, or we just saw something that will SERIOUSLY screw with the LOST time-space continuum. Bring it!!!
In other Craphole Island news...
- The 'shipper stuff was on a back burner tonight, and I'm okay with that. It still seems like Sawyer wants it to work out with Juliet, but she's a smart gal and realizes that having the others back will change everything. But the various Juliet-Kate, Kate-Sawyer, Jack-Kate, etc. scenes were all relatively straightforward and low on the longing-glances scale, and that's fine with me.
- Hurley both as a Dharma cook AND as the "hub" of info makes me happy!
- So now we've seen more of the stories of the Oceanic 6 getting back on the plane. I can't wait to see Hurley's!
- A reference to Ann Arbor! Could the deGroots be far behind?
It looks like next week's ep is going to be all about the aftermath of Sayid's escape. I can not wait to find out what happens to little Ben!









